Lyniate Team

Three Challenges FHIR 4 Faces

May 28, 2019

DaVinci Aims to Boost Payer-Provider Interoperability - read


In January 2019, HL7 published the fourth release of their FHIR (Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources) standard. While this release was notable due to the standard passing the normative ballot — meaning future changes will be backward compatible — FHIR 4 still faces challenges when it comes to solving interoperability issues in healthcare IT.

Three of the obstacles that the FHIR 4 standard faces are:

  • Security
  • Expectations
  • Integrating with legacy approaches


Security of both access control and data-in-transit is always paramount — regardless of the data standard used to exchange information.

While FHIR is not a proper security standard, it does provide:

  • Security guidance for implementers, and
  • Internal security structure (such as audit resources)

Access our latest FHIR Resources.

Addressing the overreaching goal of security in conjunction with the workflow and business requirements is a must. For example, FHIR recommends OAuth for authentication, but the specific details around the implementation of OAuth must be addressed by the implementers or via a realm-specific agreement.

The SMART App Launch was also recently released, and it provides reliable, secure authorization for a variety of app architectures wanting to connect to EHR data via a FHIR system.

FHIR will mostly enable lower-friction data exchanges, which will then lead to more security discussions and concerns.


Because we are early in the implementation cycle and there are deep, pent-up demands to solve a wide range of interoperability concerns urgently, over-hyped expectations for FHIR are pervasive.

FHIR’s ability to query source-of-truth systems in real time and its improved data model reducing friction for data exchange makes sugarplums dance in the minds of most stakeholders.

The reality will be much more difficult. Even allowing that FHIR is a dramatically and transformationally better approach to interoperability, no single standard will meet the panacea about which everyone dreams.

Legacy Interoperability Approaches

Established interoperability infrastructure is not going away — or anytime soon at least.

From integration engines to data lakes with CDA documents, the existing approaches to data exchange will continue for decades. FHIR will not replace V2 nor CDA. Rather, it will augment the existing solutions.

The key to having FHIR improve interoperability will be effectively integrating the transaction-oriented standards (V2, CDA, X12, SCRIPT, etc.) with the interaction-orientated FHIR standard.

Despite these challenges, the future is bright.


Related Blogs

Lyniate_Rapid_illustration_api_gateway_manager (1)

Lyniate Team

Lyniate introduces Rapid, a healthcare API gateway

Rapid is a healthcare API gateway and manager designed to help health teams create and safeguard APIs, including Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources (FHIR)-based APIs like those required by the CMS Interoperability and Patient Access Rule.

Read more

Austin Dobson

What payers need to know about integrating clinical data

Read more

Stephan Rubin

4 Tips for Successful EHR Interoperability

Read more